Suggestions by @vincentwilliamsiii

John Krasinski

as Bruce Wayne in Superman II (Superman/Batman)

Score: +1

Ian Somerhalder

as Kal-El/Clark Kent in Superman II (Superman/Batman)

Score: +1

Rian Johnson

as Director in Task Force X I

Score: +1

Ian Somerhalder

as Kal-El/Clark Kent in Task Force X I

Score: +1

Giovanni Ribisi

as Johnny Viti in Batman II (Batman & Robin)

Score: +1

Zack Snyder

as Director in Batman II (Batman & Robin)

Score: +1

Neal McDonough

as Victor Fries in Batman II (Batman & Robin)

Score: +1

Emily Blunt

as Selina Kyle in Batman II (Batman & Robin)

Score: 0

John Krasinski

as Bruce Wayne in Batman II (Batman & Robin)

Score: +1

Ian Somerhalder

as Kal-El/Clark Kent in Justice League I

Score: +1

John Krasinski

as Bruce Wayne in Justice League I

Score: +1

Maggie Gyllenhaal

as Wanda Maximoff in Avengers 3

Score: +1

Peter Sarsgaard

as Vision in Avengers 3

Score: +1

Rossif Sutherland

as Simon Williams in Avengers 3

Score: +1

Maggie Gyllenhaal

as Wanda Maximoff in Avengers 2

Score: +1

Rossif Sutherland

as Simon Williams in Avengers 2

Score: +1

Danny Woodburn

as Krona in Lantern Corps Series S1

Score: +1

Paul Rudd

as Tony Stark in Avengers 2

Score: 0

Seth Rogen

as Harold "Happy" Hogan in The Initiative Series S2

Score: +1

David Schwimmer

as Reed Richards in Fantastic Four 1

Score: +1