Suggestions by @vilgotek2

Derek Mears

as Jason Voorhees in Horror Cinematic Universe

Score: +3

Ansel Elgort

as Masky in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +2

The Rake

as The Rake in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

Chris Diamantopoulos

as Suicide Mouse in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

Jennifer Lawrence

as Clockwork in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: 0

Mckenna Grace

as Sally in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

Lily Collins

as Nina The Killer in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +2

Tom Holland

as Glitchy Red in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

aj mitchell

as Eyeless Jack in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: 0

Jack Quaid

as Hoodie in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

Bill Skarsgård

as Laughing Jack in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +3

Ben Schwartz

as Sonic.exe in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +2

Finn Wolfhard

as Jeff The Killer in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

This Man

as This Man in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +3

Pedro Pascal

as Herobrine in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +2

Husky

as Smile Dog in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +3

Rodger Bumpass

as Squidward Suicide in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1

Aiden Lovekamp

as Ben Drowned in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +2

Michelle Rodriguez

as Jane The Killer in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: -1

Josh Hutcherson

as Ticci Toby in Creepypasta Cinematic Universe

Score: +1