Suggestions by @victordukes

Donald Faison

as Pete Ross in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Michelle Monaghan

as Lana Lang in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Jane Krakowski

as Cat Grant in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Kurtwood Smith

as Frank Berkowitz in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Bruce Willis

as David Corporon in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Sam Elliott

as Gen. Sam Lane in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Natalie Dormer

as Kara Zor-El/Kara Kent in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Tyler James Williams

as Pete Ross in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Patrick J. Adams

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Emma Stone

as Lana Lang in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Jon Voight

as President Franklin D. Roosevelt in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Famke Janssen

as Lara-El in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Liam Neeson

as Jor-El in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Christina Hendricks

as Eve Teschmacher in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Karen Allen

as Martha Kent in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Harrison Ford

as Jonathan Kent in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Alec Baldwin

as Perry White in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Tyler James Williams

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Piper Perabo

as Cat Grant in Superman 1941

Score: +1

Olivia Wilde

as Lois Lane in Superman 1941

Score: +1