Suggestions by @venusa

Pedro Pascal

as Alejandro Murrieta in The Mask of Zorro (2022 Remake)

Score: +14

David Westhead

as Mr. John Tate in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +4

Rusty Goffe

as Mr. John Tate in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +1

Peter Wight

as Mr. John Tate in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +1

John Carroll Lynch

as Mr. John Tate in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +4

Amarr M. Wooten

as Gabe Santora in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +1

Myles Truitt

as Gabe Santora in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +5

Caleb McLaughlin

as Gabe Santora in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +6

Chosen Jacobs

as Gabe Santora in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: -1

Miles Brown

as Gabe Santora in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +3

Nancy Cartwright

as Mrs. Karen Olson in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +2

Yeardley Smith

as Mrs. Karen Olson in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: -1

Maureen Brennan

as Mrs. Karen Olson in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +3

Sarah Lancashire

as Mrs. Karen Olson in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +4

Justin Long

as Professor Edward Furlong in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: -1

Adam Devine

as Professor Edward Furlong in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +2

Ioan Gruffudd

as Professor Edward Furlong in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: -1

Matt Smith

as Professor Edward Furlong in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +3

Jesse Eisenberg

as Professor Edward Furlong in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: +1

Michael Cera

as Professor Edward Furlong in The Faculty (2022 Remake)

Score: 0