Suggestions by @venusa

Miles Heizer

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +1

Taylor Lautner

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +4

Logan Lerman

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +4

Leo Howard

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: 0

Ethan Cutkosky

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +1

Dean-Charles Chapman

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +1

Mason Cook

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +2

Fionn Whitehead

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +2

Jacob Bertrand

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: 0

Jacob Elordi

as Matt Donovan in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +5

Matteo Andrea Barbaria

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +4

Gavin Leatherwood

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +9

Ricardo Hoyos

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +5

Tanner Fontana

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +6

Karl Kugelmann

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: 0

Milo Manheim

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +8

Felix Mallard

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +3

Alex Wolff

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +2

Asa Butterfield

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: -1

Xolo Maridueña

as Tyler Lockwood in Vampire Diaries (2022 Remake)

Score: +5