Suggestions by @user_79769

Winona Ryder

as Carmela Corleone in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Michael Keaton

as Salvatore Tessio in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Sean Astin

as Luca Brasi in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Brett Gelman

as Virgil Sollozzo in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +1

Asa Butterfield

as Carlo Rizzi in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +3

Emma Stone

as Kay Adams in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +3

Mark Williams

as Capo Peter Clemenza in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +3

Emma Mackey

as Connie Corleone in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Tom Hagen in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Dacre Montgomery

as Fredo Corleone in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Jesse Eisenberg

as Sonny Corleone in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: +1

Bill Hader

as Michael Corleone in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: -1

David Harbour

as Vito Corleone in THE GODFATHER (REMAKE)

Score: 0

David Harbour

as Frankie Carbone in GOODFELLAS (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Sean Astin

as Tuddy Cicero in GOODFELLAS (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Enrique Arce

as Morrie Kessler in GOODFELLAS (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Mark Williams

as Paul Cicero in GOODFELLAS (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Natalia Dyer

as Karen Hill in GOODFELLAS (REMAKE)

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Henry Hill in GOODFELLAS (REMAKE)

Score: 0

Jim Breuer

as Tommy DeVito in GOODFELLAS (REMAKE)

Score: 0