Suggestions by @user_36783

Austin Abrams

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +1

Robbie Kay

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +2

Jared Gilmore

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +1

Asher Angel

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +2

Ross Lynch

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +1

Dylan Sprayberry

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +1

Thomas Doherty

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +2

Josh Hutcherson

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +3

Zac Efron

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: -1

Dylan Sprouse

as Connor Stoll in Riordanverse

Score: +2

Jack Gore

as Peter Pan in Peter Pan

Score: -1

Justin Tinucci

as Peter Pan in Peter Pan

Score: -1

Shane Cambria

as Peter Pan in Peter Pan

Score: -1

Ryan Turner

as Peter Pan in Peter Pan

Score: -1

Mason Shea Joyce

as Slightly in Peter Pan

Score: +2

Bradley Bundlie

as Slightly in Peter Pan

Score: +2

Luke Andrew Kruntchev

as Slightly in Peter Pan

Score: +2

Finn Carr

as Slightly in Peter Pan

Score: +2

Theo De Almeida

as Tootles in Peter Pan

Score: +2

Jude Law

as Captain Hook in Peter Pan

Score: +3