Suggestions by @user_359813

Tyler Hoechlin

as Logan/Wolverine in The X-Men

Score: 0

Jane Levy

as Jean Grey in The X-Men

Score: +1

Brenton Thwaites

as Scott Summers/Cyclops in The X-Men

Score: 0

James McAvoy

as Charlies Xavier in The X-Men

Score: +3

Tim Roth

as Emil Blonsky in The Incredible Hulk

Score: +1

William Hurt

as Thaddeus Ross in The Incredible Hulk

Score: +1

Liv Tyler

as Betty Ross in The Incredible Hulk

Score: +1

Edward Norton

as Bruce Banner/The Hulk in The Incredible Hulk

Score: +1

Jon Hamm

as Victor Von Doom/Doctor Doom in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Nicolas Cage

as Johnny Blaze/Ghost Rider in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Chris Evans

as Johnny Storm/Human Torch in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Ben Affleck

as Matt Murdock/DareDevil in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Wesley Snipes

as Eric Brooks/Blade in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Jessica Alba

as Sue Storm/Invisible Woman in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Patrick Stewart

as Charlies Xavier in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Michael Chiklis

as Ben Grimm/The Thing in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Michael Culkin

as Ben Grimm/The Thing in The Avengers 2000s

Score: -2

Hugh Jackman

as Logan/Wolverine in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Nick Fury in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2

Ioan Gruffudd

as Reed Richards/Mr. Fantastic in The Avengers 2000s

Score: +2