Suggestions by @user_304932

Mark Ballas

as Earl in Waitress Broadway Revival

Score: +2

Andrew Keenan-Bolger

as Ogie in Waitress Broadway Revival

Score: +1

Erika Henningsen

as Dawn in Waitress Broadway Revival

Score: +1

Alex Newell

as Becky in Waitress Broadway Revival

Score: +1

Jelani Alladin

as Dr Pomatter in Waitress Broadway Revival

Score: +1

Phillipa Soo

as Jenna in Waitress Broadway Revival

Score: +1

Alan Cumming

as The Wonderful Wizard of Oz in Wicked The Movie

Score: +1

Shanice Williams

as Nessarose in Wicked The Movie

Score: +1

Juno Temple

as Effe Trinket in The Hunger Games (Recast)

Score: +2

Brody Grant

as Orpheus in Hadestown (Live-Action)

Score: 0

Alex Newell

as Sour Kangaroo in Seussical

Score: +1

Leslie Kritzer

as Mayzie La Bird in Seussical

Score: +1

Kimiko Glenn

as Gertrude McFuzz in Seussical

Score: +1

Alex Brightman

as Horton in Seussical

Score: +1

John Tartaglia

as Mr. Mayor in Seussical

Score: +1

Cole Escola

as Cat In The Hat in Seussical

Score: +1

Avi Kaplan

as Hades in Hadestown (2025)

Score: 0

Kit Connor

as Orpheus in Hadestown (2025)

Score: 0

Blythe Jandoo

as Fate #2 in Hadestown West End

Score: +1

Gabriella Stylianou

as Fate #1 in Hadestown West End

Score: +1