Suggestions by @user_29421

Chris Pratt

as Sidney in I'll Always love you

Score: +1

Helen Mirren

as Madame Germaute in The Phantom and the Soprano

Score: +2

Christoph Waltz

as Monsieur Ruber in The Phantom and the Soprano

Score: +2

Chris Pratt

as Erik/ The Phantom in The Phantom and the Soprano

Score: +1

Evanna Lynch

as Ms. Fleck in Love Never Dies Movie Musical

Score: 0

Kathy Najimy

as Madame Giry in Love Never Dies Movie Musical

Score: 0

Dove Cameron

as Meg Giry in Love Never Dies Movie Musical

Score: +1

Scott Cohen

as The Phantom/ Erik in Love Never Dies Movie Musical

Score: 0

Richard Madden

as Raoul in Love Never Dies Movie Musical

Score: +1

Sierra Boggess

as Christine Daee in Love Never Dies Movie Musical

Score: +8

Tom Ellis

as The Phantom/ Erik in Love Never Dies Movie Musical

Score: +1

Chris Pratt

as The Phantom/ Erik in Love Never Dies Live

Score: +1

Jeremy Jordan

as Porter in The phantom of the opera live

Score: +1

Dane Agostinis

as Monsieur Reyer in The phantom of the opera live

Score: +1

Drew Seeley

as Joseph Buquet in The phantom of the opera live

Score: +1

Hugh Panaro

as Monsieur LeFevre in The phantom of the opera live

Score: +1

Phumzile Sojola

as Piangi in The phantom of the opera live

Score: +1

Storm Lineberger

as Auctioneer in The phantom of the opera live

Score: +1

Kelsey Grammer

as Doll doctor in Raggedy Ann a musical Adventure live

Score: +1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as The wolf in Raggedy Ann a musical Adventure live

Score: +2