Suggestions by @user_24648

Fionn Whitehead

as The Gay One in Typical Teen Movie/Television Series

Score: +1

Miles Heizer

as The Gay One in Typical Teen Movie/Television Series

Score: +17

Herizen F. Guardiola

as The Goth in Typical Teen Movie/Television Series

Score: +11

Jack Haven

as The Goth in Typical Teen Movie/Television Series

Score: 0

Kaya Scodelario

as Elizabeth Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +4

Kristen Stewart

as Karen Pomeroy in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Alexa Demie

as Gretchen Ross in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Laura Harrier

as Gretchen Ross in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Austin Abrams

as Donnie Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Lucas Hedges

as Donnie Darko in Donnie Darko

Score: +1

Rachel True

as Ms.Fleming in Heathers: The Musical

Score: -1

Rachel True

as Pauline fleming in Heathers the musical

Score: 0

Rachel True

as Cassie in Animorphs (The Animated Series)

Score: +1

Dane DeHaan

as Tobias in Animorphs (The Animated Series)

Score: +1

Rachel True

as Ms Fleming in Heathers: The Musical

Score: 0

Rachel True

as Mrs. Fleming in Heathers

Score: +1

Keke Palmer

as Heather Chandler in Heathers

Score: 0

Halle Bailey

as Heather McNamara in Heathers

Score: +1

Alisha Boe

as Heather Duke in Heathers

Score: +2

Steven Yeun

as Hedrick Chapman in Animorphs

Score: 0