Suggestions by @user_241930

Lilly Aspell

as Alice in Magic Hour

Score: +1

Blake Lively

as Ellie Barton in Magic Hour

Score: -2

Patrick Dempsey

as Dr. Max Cerrasin in Magic Hour

Score: +3

Danielle Savre

as Dr. Julia Cates in Magic Hour

Score: +1

Elizabeth Mitchell

as Dr. Julia Cates in Magic Hour

Score: +2