Suggestions by @user_233048

Goran Višnjić

as Gerlach in Pirate Tigers 1

Score: +1

Alex Rochon

as Vespa in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Josh Hutcherson

as Vetis in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Christian Borle

as Verin in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +1

James Monroe Iglehart

as Leeson in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Tara Strong

as Mindy in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Jennifer Lopez

as Ms.Cide in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Roger Craig Smith

as Dan in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Rory McCann

as Major Styx in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Tabitha St. Germain

as Tentadora in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Stephanie Beatriz

as Narissa in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Edward Bosco

as Lucifer in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: 0

Simon Callow

as Fabian in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Jack McBrayer

as Zechariah in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Jason LaShea

as Alanzo in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Kelly Sheridan

as Jackie in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Diedrich Bader

as Autumn in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2

Ben Diskin

as Rusty in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +3

Sam Haft

as Vincent in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +3

Alex Brightman

as Leo in Zoophobia S1 episode 1

Score: +2