Suggestions by @user_177144

Hailee Steinfeld

as Bellatrix Lestrange in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Alexa Demie

as Bellatrix Lestrange in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +3

Margaret Qualley

as Bellatrix Lestrange in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +3

Madhuri Dixit

as Euphemia Potter in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Charlie Heaton

as Alastor Moody in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +2

Simone Ashley

as Euphemia Potter in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +2

Meryl Streep

as Euphemia Potter in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Pedro Pascal

as Fleamont Potter in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +1

Jeremy Ray Taylor

as Peter Pettigrew in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +2

Elden Henson

as Peter Pettigrew in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +2

Annalise Basso

as Lily Evans in Marauders Fan cast

Score: +5

Alycia Pascual-Peña

as Mary Macdonald in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Malia Baker

as Mary Macdonald in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Marsai Martin

as Mary Macdonald in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Sofia Wylie

as Mary Macdonald in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Alexandra Shipp

as Mary Macdonald in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Helena Howard

as Mary Macdonald in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: 0

Bailey Bass

as Mary Macdonald in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +2

Barbie Ferreira

as Alice Fortescue in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: -1

Lucas Lynggaard Tønnesen

as Xenophilius Lovegood in The Marauders Era Fancasts

Score: +2