Suggestions by @tysargent

Ben Platt

as Seymour Krelborn in Little Shop of Horrors (2021 film)

Score: 0

Russ Walko

as Puppeteers in The Muppet Man (Jim Henson BioPic)

Score: +1

Cookie Monster

as Beast/Prince Adam in Beauty and the Beast (2017)

Score: -2

Red Fraggle

as Genie in Aladdin (2019 Alternate FanCast)

Score: 0

Mark Hamill

as Genie in Aladdin (2019 Alternate FanCast)

Score: 0

Uncle Deadly

as Claude Frollo in Hunchback of Notre Dame (2024)

Score: -2

Kevin McTurk

as Charlie McCarthy Puppeteer #2 in Henson

Score: +1

Christopher Lloyd

as Voice of Charlie McCarthy in Henson

Score: +1

Christopher Lloyd

as Edgar Bergen in Henson

Score: +1

Norman Tempia

as Charlie McCarthy Puppeteer #2 in Henson

Score: +1

Darci Lynne Farmer

as Charlie McCarthy Puppeteer #1 in Henson

Score: +1

Brian Michael Jones

as Puppeteer #4 in Henson

Score: +1

Grant Baciocco

as Puppeteer #3 in Henson

Score: +1

Colleen Smith

as Puppeteer #2 in Henson

Score: +1

Russ Walko

as Puppeteer #1 in Henson

Score: +1

Dave Goelz

as Cameos in Henson

Score: +1

Susan Schechter

as Executive Producer in Little Shop of Horrors (2021 film)

Score: +1

David Geffen

as Executive Producer in Little Shop of Horrors (2021 film)

Score: +1

Allan Trautman

as Audrey II Principal Puppeteers in Little Shop of Horrors (2021 film)

Score: +1

Carmen Osbahr

as Audrey II Principal Puppeteers in Little Shop of Horrors (2021 film)

Score: +1