Suggestions by @turnintoabird

Tim Heidecker

as Dexter Vex in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Jeremy Strong

as Nefarian Serpine in Skulduggery Pleasant (2023 Live-Action Film)

Score: +1

Jeremy Strong

as Nefarian Serpine in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: 0

Henry Simmons

as Solomon Wreath in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as Erskine Ravel in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Antony Starr

as Doctor Nye in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Joel Fry

as Mister Miracle in Suicide Squad (TV Series)

Score: +1

Elliot Page

as Mister Miracle in Suicide Squad (TV Series)

Score: -1

Iain De Caestecker

as Dusk in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Travis Willingham

as Baron Vengeous [post credits scene] in Skulduggery Pleasant (2023 Live-Action Film)

Score: +2

Travis Willingham

as Baron Vengeous in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +2

Will Arnett

as Dexter Vex in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: 0

Bill Hader

as Dexter Vex in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: 0

David Castañeda

as Saracen Rue in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: 0

Jason Bateman

as Jaron Gallow in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Michael Cera

as Erskine Ravel in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Cameron Britton

as Solomon Wreath in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: -1

Toheeb Jimoh

as Dusk in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +2

Charlie Day

as Vandameer Craven in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1

Glenn Howerton

as Doctor Nye in Skulduggery Pleasant

Score: +1