Suggestions by @truebrawler2763

Andy Samberg

as Hammy in Over the Hedge (2016)

Score: +1

Brett Gelman

as Skipper in Madagascar

Score: +1

Lee Majdoub

as Panic in Hercules

Score: +1

Eduardo Franco

as Sid in Ice Age (Live-Action)

Score: +1

Ed Helms

as Vecna in Scary movie 6

Score: 0

Will Arnett

as Foxy in Scary movie 6

Score: +4

Ben Schwartz

as Sonic.EXE in Scary movie 6

Score: +3

Thomas Haden Church

as King Bowser Koopa in Don Bluth's Super Mario Bros. (1990's)

Score: +1

Pete Davidson

as Blam in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +2

Lance Thirtyacre

as Woody in Toy Story

Score: +1

Lance Thirtyacre

as Shrek in Shrek

Score: +2

Chris Diamantopoulos

as Scratchy in The Simpsons

Score: +1

Jack Black

as Golden Flumpty/Shaw Delot in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +2

Danny McBride

as Grunkfuss in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +2

Ken Jeong

as Redman in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +2

Dylan O'Brien

as Gabe/Main Character in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +1

No Voice Actor

as Phantom Hank in Jeffy's Infinite Irida (Horror)

Score: +1

Zach Galifianakis

as Flumpty in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +2

Five Nights At Freddy's (2023)

as Inspirations in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +2

Scary Movie (2000 Film)

as Inspirations in One Night At Flumpty's (Horror)

Score: +2