Suggestions by @tracygjackson2011

William Forsythe

as John Milton in Scream 3 (2010)

Jamie Johnston

as Roman Bridger in Scream 3 (2010)

Yan-Kay Crystal Lowe

as Angelina Tyler in Scream 3 (2010)

Allison Janney

as Bianca in Scream 3 (2010)

Amy Jo Johnson

as Maureen Prescott (neé Roberts) in Scream 3 (2010)

Leslie Bibb

as Jennifer Jolie in Scream 3 (2010)

Triple H

as Steven Stone in Scream 3 (2010)

Rachel Blanchard

as Christine Hamilton in Scream 3 (2010)

Tyler Shea Cone

as Cotton Weary in Scream 3 (2010)

Judson Mills

as Dewey Riley in Scream 3 (2010)

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Gale Weathers in Scream 3 (2010)

Gregory Smith

as Mickey Altieri in Scream 2 (2007)

Deborah Knox

as Tori's interviewer in Scream 2 (2007)

Lauren Collins

as Sidney Prescott (character in the in-universe film Stab) in Scream 2 (2007)

Rachel McAdams

as Casey Becker (character in the in-universe film Stab) in Scream 2 (2007)

Daniella Evangelista

as Murphy in Scream 2 (2007)

Hanna Hall

as Lois in Scream 2 (2007)

Julianna Guill

as Dawnie in Scream 2 (2007)

Kyla Pratt

as Maureen Evans in Scream 2 (2007)

Drake

as Phil Stevens in Scream 2 (2007)