Suggestions by @tracygjackson2011

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Summer Roberts in The O.C. (1994-1998)

Score: +1

Josh Hartnett

as Shane FIsher in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Patrick Dempsey

as Kane Wheeler in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

David Boreanaz

as Detective Mark Kincaid in Scream 3 (2000) (Early Draft Version)

Score: +1

Jamie Blanks

as Director in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Tammy Parks

as Leslie in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Hayden Panettiere

as Jenny Melton in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Amanda Detmer

as Maxine Raimi in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Rain Phoenix

as Gina Taylor in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Tara Reid

as Brittany in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Leslie Bibb

as Janet Marquette in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Kevin Durand

as Richie WalKer in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Candace Morris in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Sheryl Lee

as Detective Lana Vaughn in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Rachel Blanchard

as Amy Carr/Jenny Melton in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Jeffrey Donovan

as Luke Voight in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

Amy Irving

as Eva Wheeler in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1

David Boreanaz

as Kane Wheeler in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: -1

Ryan Phillippe

as Richie WalKer in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: -1

Judson Mills

as Dylan Wheeler in Valentine (2001) (Genderswapped Version)

Score: +1