Suggestions by @tooncityillinois
62 suggestions

Arnold Schwarzenegger
as Mr Freeze in Tim Burton's Batman Universe

Jim Carrey
as Riddler in Tim Burton's Batman Universe

Josh Brolin
as Philip Wittebane AKA Emperor Belos in The Owl House (Alternate casting)

Robert Downey Jr.
as Alador Blight in The Owl House (Alternate casting)

Henry Cavill
as Alador Blight in The Owl House (Alternate casting)

Antony Starr
as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own (2022)

Kristen Schaal
as Marla Hooch in A League of Their Own

Antony Starr
as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own

Kyle Chandler
as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own

Jane Kaczmarek
as Joyce Byers in Stranger Things early 2000s

Jane Krakowski
as Joyce Byers in Stranger Things early 2000s

Kristen Schaal
as Marla Hooch in A League of Their Own (Just for fun cast)

Seth Rogen
as Ernie Capadino, AAGPBL scout in A League of Their Own (Just for fun cast)

Antony Starr
as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own (Just for fun cast)

Mae Whitman
as Sophia's Ghost in Kindred Spirits

Winona Ryder
as Sophia's Ghost in Kindred Spirits

Ashton Kutcher
as Frank in Sausage Party (2006)

Andrew Garfield
as Layton Deetz in Genderbent Beetlejuice

Matthew McConaughey
as Casey Kelso in That 70s Show (1988-1996)

Melinda Dillon
as Kitty Foreman in That 70s Show (1988-1996)