Suggestions by @tooncityillinois

Arnold Schwarzenegger

as Mr Freeze in Tim Burton's Batman Universe

Score: 0

Jim Carrey

as Riddler in Tim Burton's Batman Universe

Score: 0

Josh Brolin

as Philip Wittebane AKA Emperor Belos in The Owl House (Alternate casting)

Score: +1

Robert Downey Jr.

as Alador Blight in The Owl House (Alternate casting)

Score: +2

Henry Cavill

as Alador Blight in The Owl House (Alternate casting)

Score: 0

Antony Starr

as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own (2022)

Score: +1

Kristen Schaal

as Marla Hooch in A League of Their Own

Score: +1

Antony Starr

as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own

Score: +1

Kyle Chandler

as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own

Score: +1

Jane Kaczmarek

as Joyce Byers in Stranger Things early 2000s

Score: +1

Jane Krakowski

as Joyce Byers in Stranger Things early 2000s

Score: +1

Kristen Schaal

as Marla Hooch in A League of Their Own (Just for fun cast)

Score: +1

Seth Rogen

as Ernie Capadino, AAGPBL scout in A League of Their Own (Just for fun cast)

Score: 0

Antony Starr

as Jimmy Dugan in A League of Their Own (Just for fun cast)

Score: +1

Mae Whitman

as Sophia's Ghost in Kindred Spirits

Score: +1

Winona Ryder

as Sophia's Ghost in Kindred Spirits

Score: +1

Ashton Kutcher

as Frank in Sausage Party (2006)

Score: +2

Andrew Garfield

as Layton Deetz in Genderbent Beetlejuice

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Casey Kelso in That 70s Show (1988-1996)

Score: +1

Melinda Dillon

as Kitty Foreman in That 70s Show (1988-1996)

Score: +1