Suggestions by @tobeecone

Chris Hemsworth

as King Arthur in Excalibur (2022)

Score: +3

Nazanin Boniadi

as Dust in X-Men 2: MRD

Score: +1

Heath Ledger

as Red Hood in Characters who would've appeared in Chris Nolan's Batman Universe

Score: +2

Nicolas Cage

as Egghead in Characters who would've appeared in Chris Nolan's Batman Universe

Score: +2

Matt Damon

as Hush in Characters who would've appeared in Chris Nolan's Batman Universe

Score: +3

Bryan Cranston

as Jim Gordon in The Batman| Tales of Arkham

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as Victor Zsasz in Characters who would've appeared in Chris Nolan's Batman Universe

Score: +2

Vin Diesel

as Shrek in The Poopvengers

Score: 0

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Abraham Van Helsing in Dracula (2012)

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Jake in Duskwood

Score: -5

Matt Reeves

as Director in The Batman 2

Score: +2

Oscar Isaac

as Harvey Dent in The Batman 2

Score: +2

Mark Strong

as MR Freeze in The Batman 2

Score: +2

Barry Keoghan

as Joker in The Batman 2

Score: +2

Colin Farrell

as The Penguin in The Batman 2

Score: +2

Zoë Kravitz

as Selina Kyle in The Batman 2

Score: +2

Robert Pattinson

as Batman in The Batman 2

Score: +3

Josh Brolin

as Atrocitus in The Perfect Justice League Movie

Score: 0

Sean Bean

as Atrocitus in The Perfect Justice League Movie

Score: +1