Suggestions by @titusnunley

Eva Marie Saint

as Aunt May in Tim Burton's Spider-Man Returns (1992)

Score: +1

Sharon Stone

as Felicia Hardy in Tim Burton's Spider-Man Returns (1992)

Score: +2

Demi Moore

as Mary Jane Watson in Tim Burton's Spider-Man Returns (1992)

Score: +1

Christopher Lloyd

as Adrian Toomes in Tim Burton's Spider-Man Returns (1992)

Score: +1

Michael J. Fox

as Peter Parker in Tim Burton's Spider-Man Returns (1992)

Score: +2

Elisabeth Shue

as Gwen Stacy in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: 0

Eric Stoltz

as Eddie Brock in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Clyde Gatell

as Dennis Carradine in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Richard Crenna

as George Stacy in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Elisabeth Shue

as Gwen Stacy in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Sharon Holm

as Mary Parker in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

David Baxt

as Richard Parker in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Danny Elfman

as Composer in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

David Koepp

as Writer in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Stan Lee

as Producer in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Tim Burton

as Director in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Maxwell Caulfield

as Flash Thompson in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: 0

Sean Young

as Betty Brant in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: 0

Pat Hingle

as Uncle Ben in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1

Eva Marie Saint

as Aunt May in Tim Burton's Spider-Man (1989)

Score: +1