Suggestions by @titusnunley

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Spider-Man (Cameronverse) in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Andrew Garfield

as Spider-Man (Webbverse) in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Tobey Maguire

as Spider-Man (Raimiverse) in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Josh Dallas

as Richard Parker in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Linda Cardellini

as Mary Parker in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Jamie Dornan

as John Jameson in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Caleb Emery

as Kenny McFarlane in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Rudy Pankow

as Agent Venom in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Jamie Dornan

as Man-Wolf in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Lance Henriksen

as Electro II in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Tom Felton

as Electro in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Michael Biehn

as Sandman III in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Dylan O'Brien

as Scarlet-Spider II in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

John Cena

as Sandman II in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Mark Wahlberg

as Sandman in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Sammi Hanratty

as Screwball in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Amber Midthunder

as Spider-Girl in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Ansel Elgort

as Hobgoblin in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Jason Isaacs

as Green Goblin in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)

Dylan O'Brien

as Scarlet Spider in Spider-Man (Marvel Extended Universe)