Suggestions by @titocalderon

Dan Stevens

as Aragorn in Lord of the Rings Valentine's Day

Score: +2

Katheryn Winnick

as Pauline in The Super Mario Movie

Score: +2

Katheryn Winnick

as Rosalina in The Super Mario Movie

Score: +2

Chris Tucker

as Toad in The Super Mario Movie

Score: +2

Mark Henry

as Kamek in The Super Mario Movie

Score: +2

Josh Gad

as King Bowser in The Super Mario Movie

Score: +2

Mark Henry

as King Bowser in The Super Mario Movie

Score: +2

Roman Reigns

as Donkey Kong in Super Mario Bros

Score: +2

Mark Henry

as Kamek in Super Mario Bros

Score: +2

Josh Gad

as Bowser in Super Mario Bros

Score: +2

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean young version

Score: +2

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean (REMAKE)

Score: +2

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Davy Jones in Villains

Score: +2

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean trilogy (2013-2017)

Score: +1

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean Film Series (1993-2007)

Score: +2

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean (1990's)

Score: +2

Brian Doyle-Murray

as Davy Jones in Pirates of the Caribbean Trilogy (2020's)

Score: +4

Chris Tucker

as George Beard in Captain Underpants 1990s

Score: +1

Roman Reigns

as Maui in Moana

Score: +1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Flynn Rider in Tangled

Score: +1