Suggestions by @tisha

Kenajuan Bentley

as Young Fred Baxter in The Cousins

Score: +2

James Pickens Jr.

as Fred Baxter in The Cousins

Score: +5

Reid Scott

as Edward Franklin in The Cousins

Score: +2

Elizabeth Alderfer

as Young Theresa Ryan in The Cousins

Score: 0

Ashley Moore

as Kayla Dugas in The Cousins

Score: +5

Cayden Boyd

as Matt Ryan in The Cousins

Score: +1

Paris Warner

as Young Allison Story in The Cousins

Score: -1

Charles Vandervaart

as Young Anders Story in The Cousins

Score: +4

Cameron Cuffe

as Young Adam Story in The Cousins

Score: +2

Matt Cohen

as Archer Story in The Cousins

Score: -3

Kate Siegel

as Allison Story in The Cousins

Score: +3

Eoin Macken

as Anders Story in The Cousins

Score: +3

Michael Landes

as Adam Story in The Cousins

Score: +4

Kerr Smith

as Carson Fine in The Cousins

Score: -1

Linda Lavin

as Theresa Ryan in The Cousins

Score: +4

Gary Sinise

as Donald Camden in The Cousins

Score: -1

Sigourney Weaver

as Mildred Margaret Story in The Cousins

Score: +5

Aisha Dee

as Hazel Baxter-Clement in The Cousins

Score: +5

Aria Shahghasemi

as Jonah Story in The Cousins

Score: -8

McKaley Miller

as Aubrey Story in The Cousins

Score: -2