Suggestions by @timewarp

Wednesday Addams (2022)

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Daniela(through my window)

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Isabel Martinez

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Drea Torres

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Carmen “Raya” Alonso

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Maddy Perez

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Flora (Winx Club)

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Maria Garcia (Rainbow High)

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Christy Renault

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Teresa Rivera

as Choices in Characters Patty Juárez should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Katherine McNamara

as 2010s (Teen) in Willow Rosenberg, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +3

Lindsay Lohan

as 2000s (Teen) in Willow Rosenberg, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +3

Molly Ringwald

as '90s (Young Adult) in Willow Rosenberg, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Molly Ringwald

as '80s (Teen) in Willow Rosenberg, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Lisa Pelikan

as '70s (Teen) in Willow Rosenberg, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Deborah Walley

as 60s (Teen) in Willow Rosenberg, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Debbie Reynolds

as '50s (Teen) in Willow Rosenberg, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Melissa Joan Hart

as '90s (Teen) in Glinda Upland, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Olivia D'Abo

as '80s (Teen) in Glinda Upland, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2

Brandy Norwood

as 90s (Teen) in Elphaba Thropp, From Decades Life Cycle

Score: +2