Suggestions by @timewarp

Alison Sweeney

as Cindy Clark in Savage Streets (1994)

Score: +1

Melissa Joan Hart

as Heather in Savage Streets (1994)

Score: +2

Stacey Dash

as Stella in Savage Streets (1994)

Score: +2

Jamie Luner

as Stevie in Savage Streets (1994)

Score: +2

Penélope Cruz

as Maria in Savage Streets (1994)

Score: +2

Parker Posey

as Francine Ramirez in Savage Streets (1994)

Score: +2

A. J. Langer

as Brenda in Savage Streets (1994)

Score: +2

Wes Craven

as Director in Whistle (1995)

Score: +2

Alicia Silverstone

as Grace Browning in Whistle (1995)

Score: +2

Donald Faison

as Dean Jackson in Whistle (1995)

Score: +2

Liv Tyler

as Ellie Gains in Whistle (1995)

Score: +2

Fairuza Balk

as Chrys Willet in Whistle (1995)

Score: +2

Lara Jean

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Avery Madden

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Claudia Kishi

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Marisa Song

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Veronica (Saved!)

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Hay Lin

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Lonnie (Descendants)

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2

Ally Harris

as Choices in Characters Susie Elene should have played in the '80s

Score: +2