Suggestions by @thyralibre

Victoria Pedretti

as Juniper Hayward in Yellowface

Score: +2

Adeline Rudolph

as Athena Ling En Liu in Yellowface

Score: +1

Jordan Davis

as Liam in Red & White

Score: +1

Joy Crookes

as Snowdrop Lewis in Red & White

Score: +1

Tate McRae

as Scarlett Rosenthal in Red & White

Score: +1

Neelofa

as Dr. Khader in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Giselle Blondet

as Maureen Reyes in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Asher Angel

as Ryan Bell in Priest

Score: +1

Theo James

as Aiden Bell in Priest

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Sean Bell in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Natalia Sánchez

as Penelope Middleton Haverford in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Marc Clotet

as Sterling Haverford III in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Jason Morgan

as Anton Rees in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Walker Hayes

as Jordan Brady in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Jennifer Hudson

as Professor Courtney Morales in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Alfre Woodard

as Mildred Gustaferson in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Ana de Armas

as Poppy Danforth Bell in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Jamie Dornan

as Tyler Anselm Bell in Midnight Mass

Score: +1

Walker Hayes

as Jordan Brady in Priest

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Sean Bell in Priest

Score: +1