Suggestions by @theshawshankerection

Andy Serkis

as The Creature from the Black Lagoon in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Toby Kebbell

as The Creature from the Black Lagoon in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Ralph Fiennes

as Abraham Van Helsing in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Tom Hiddleston

as Dr. Victor Frankenstein in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Tilda Swinton

as Bride of Frankenstein in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Javier Bardem

as Frankenstein's Monster in Dark Universe

Score: +2

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

as The Wolfman in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Oscar Isaac

as The Wolfman in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Rami Malek

as The Mummy in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Paul Bettany

as Dr. Jekyll/Mr. Hyde in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Adam Driver

as Dracula in Dark Universe

Score: +1

Regina King

as Daisy Fitzroy in Bioshock Infinite

Score: +1

Oliver Jackson-Cohen

as Robert Lutece in Bioshock Infinite

Score: +1

Paul Bettany

as Robert Lutece in Bioshock Infinite

Score: +2

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Booker DeWitt in Bioshock Infinite

Score: -3

Hong Chau

as Yi Suchong in Bioshock

Score: +1

Claes Bang

as Sander Cohen in Bioshock

Score: +1

Jean Dujardin

as Sander Cohen in Bioshock

Score: +1

Julius Avery

as Director in Bioshock

Score: -1

Guillermo del Toro

as Producer in Bioshock

Score: +2