Suggestions by @theprydonianchapter

Jack Coleman

as Henry Peter Gyrich in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: -1

Victor Garber

as Franklin Storm in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: +1

Phillip Seymour Hoffman

as Mad Thinker in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: +1

Ryan Gosling

as Human Torch in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: +1

Jude Law

as Mr. Fantastic in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: +1

Kate Winslet

as Invisible Woman in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: +1

Ben Affleck

as The Thing in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: +1

Jude Law

as Mr. Fantastic in Fantastic Four (2000)(story removed)

Score: -1