Suggestions by @thepopsorcerer

Tobey Maguire

as Spider-Man in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man 4

Score: +4

Andrew Garfield

as Spider-Man in The Amazing Spider-Man 3

Score: +3

Tobey Maguire

as Spence Olchin in King Of Queens

Score: +1

Akwafina

as Toadette in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +1

Sofia Carson

as Rosalina in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +1

Fred Armisen

as Cranky Kong in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +4

Kevin Michael Richardson

as Kamek in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +2

Keegan-Michael Key

as Toad in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +1

Seth Rogen

as Donkey Kong in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +1

Steve Buscemi

as Waluigi in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +1

Danny DeVito

as Wario in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +1

Sebastian Maniscalco

as Spike in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +3

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Princess Peach in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +3

Anna Kendrick

as Princess Daisy in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +7

Jack Black

as Bowser in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +1

Charlie Day

as Luigi in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: +5

Chris Pratt

as Mario in Super Mario Bros. Animated Movie

Score: -1

Zachary Levi

as Star-Lord in Marvel Cinematic Universe (Alternate Version)

Score: +1

Morena Baccarin

as The Wasp in Marvel Cinematic Universe (Alternate Version)

Score: +1

Jean-Claude Van Damme

as Nicholas J. Fury in Marvel Cinematic Universe (Alternate Version)

Score: +1