Suggestions by @thepinkmenace

Edward Norton

as Lex Luthor in All-Star Superman

Score: +2

Courteney Cox

as Lois Lane in All-Star Superman

Score: +4

Brendan Fraser

as Superman in All-Star Superman

Score: +5

Deborah Lynn Scott

as Costume Designer in All-Star Superman

Score: +1

Rick Carter

as Production Designer in All-Star Superman

Score: +1

Michael Kahn

as Editor in All-Star Superman

Score: +1

Janusz Kamiński

as Cinematographer in All-Star Superman

Score: +1

John Williams

as Composer in All-Star Superman

Score: +2

Frank Marshall

as Producer in All-Star Superman

Score: +2

Kathleen Kennedy

as Producer in All-Star Superman

Score: +2

David Koepp

as Writer in All-Star Superman

Score: +2

Steven Spielberg

as Director in All-Star Superman

Score: +5

Leslie David Baker

as Doc Louis in 𝙋𝙐𝙉𝘾𝙃 𝙊𝙐𝙏

Score: +1

Hildur Guðnadóttir

as Composer in Hulk: Gray

Score: +2

Ken Page

as Cornbread in Sinners (1995)

Score: +1

Queen Latifah

as Annie in Sinners (1995)

Score: +2

Stefania Cella

as Production Designer in Dracula

Score: +1

Kasia Walicka Maimone

as Costume Designer in Dracula

Score: +1

J. Miles Dale

as Producer in Dracula

Score: +2

Dylan Tichenor

as Editor in Dracula

Score: +1