Suggestions by @themiscgeek

Harrison Ford

as Han Solo in Star Wars Legends Sequel Trilogy

Score: +2

Mark Hamill

as Luke Skywalker in Star Wars Legends Sequel Trilogy

Score: +2

Hayden Panettiere

as Ahsoka Tano in Star Wars: The Clone Wars Live-Action

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Strange Man in Red Dead Redemption: Morgan's Story - Aftermath

Score: +1

Noah Schnapp

as Sonic in Nintendo Extended Universe

Score: +1

Luca Marinelli

as Solid Snake in Nintendo Extended Universe

Score: +1

Luca Marinelli

as Solid Snake in Metal Gear Solid

Score: +1

Matthew Wood

as Battle-Droids in Star Wars: The Clone Wars Live-Action

Score: +1

Anson Mount

as Christopher Pike in Star Trek: The Revised Series

Score: +1

Dan Jeannotte

as Samuel Kirk in Star Trek: The Revised Series

Score: +1

Anton Yelchin

as Pavel Chekov in Star Trek Kelvin Timeline Expanded

Score: +1

John Cho

as Hikaru Sulu in Star Trek Kelvin Timeline Expanded

Score: +1

Jess Bush

as Christine Chapel in Star Trek: The Revised Series

Score: +1

Martin Quinn

as Montgomery Scott in Star Trek: The Revised Series

Score: +1

Celia Rose Gooding

as Nyota Uhura in Star Trek: The Revised Series

Score: +1

Ethan Peck

as Spock in Star Trek: The Revised Series

Score: +1

Paul Wesley

as James Kirk in Star Trek: The Revised Series

Score: +1

James Jude Courtney

as Michael Myers in Freddy vs. Jason vs. Michael vs. Ash

Score: +1

Heather Langenkamp

as Nancy Thompson in Freddy vs. Jason vs. Michael vs. Ash

Score: +1

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Laurie Strode in Freddy vs. Jason vs. Michael vs. Ash

Score: +1