Suggestions by @theletterkaye

Emily Bader

as Hazel Bradford in Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating

Score: +1

Theo Rossi

as Yan in The Bromance Book Club

Score: +1

Alison Williams

as Tarin Taylor in How My Neighbor Stole Christmas

Score: +1

Abigail Cowen

as Storee Taylor in How My Neighbor Stole Christmas

Score: +1

Damian Hardung

as Jacks in Caraval

Score: +5

Matthew Broome

as Julian in Caraval

Score: -3

Josh Hutcherson

as Graham Remington in Their Vicious Games

Score: 0

Isabel May

as Hawthorne in Their Vicious Games

Score: +3

Harris Dickinson

as Pierce Maxwell Remington IV in Their Vicious Games

Score: -1

Sammi Hanratty

as Esme Alderidge in Their Vicious Games

Score: 0

Kiernan Shipka

as Rory in Hearts Still Beating

Score: +1

Piper Curda

as Carter in Hearts Still Beating

Score: +1

Piper Curda

as Rory in Hearts Still Beating

Score: +1

Saylor Curda

as Mara in Hearts Still Beating

Score: +1

Deborah Ann Woll

as Julie in Fall I Want

Score: +1

Brant Daugherty

as Alex in Fall I Want

Score: +1

Maia Mitchell

as Harper in Fall I Want

Score: +1

Sara Waisglass

as Harper in Fall I Want

Score: +1

Joe Alwyn

as Sebastian in Fall I Want

Score: +1

Zoey Deutch

as Autumn in Fall I Want

Score: +1