Suggestions by @theguycasts

Gene Hackman

as Commissioner Loeb in Batman: Year One (2004)

Score: +4

Michael Cudlitz

as Arnold Flass in Batman: Year One (2004)

Score: +4

James Caan

as Carmine Falcone in Batman: Year One (2004)

Score: +5

Rosario Dawson

as Catwoman in Batman: Year One (2004)

Score: +5

Michael Gambon

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Year One (2004)

Score: +6

Kurt Russell

as Captain Gordon in Batman: Year One (2004)

Score: +5

Josh Hartnett

as Batman in Batman: Year One (2004)

Score: +5

Lee Pace

as Post Credit Scene in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Spoiler

as Post Credit Scene in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Amanda Seyfried

as Alicia Masters in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Sarah Sherman

as H.E.R.B.I.E. in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Caleb Landry Jones

as Electro in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Jamie Lee Curtis

as Aunt May in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +1

Rachel Sennott

as Betty Brant in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Tim Meadows

as Robbie Robertson in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Michael Shannon

as J. Jonah Jameson in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Rachel Zegler

as Mary Jane Watson in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +1

Sam Witwer

as Super Skrull in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Nicholas Alexander Chavez

as Human Torch in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2

Zac Efron

as The Thing in Spider-Man vs. The Fantastic Four

Score: +2