Suggestions by @thegingerbreadman

Chris Pine

as Hal Jordan in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Hal Jordan in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: 0

Liev Schreiber

as Sgt. Franklin John Rock in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +1

Luca Guadagnino

as Sgt. Rock Director in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +1

Christopher MacDonald

as Ron Troupe in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Hal Jordan in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +1

Damson Idris

as John Stewart in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +1

Kumail Nanjiani

as Booster Gold in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: 0

Ivanna Sakhno

as Illyana Rasputin in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: 0

Robert Patrick

as Reverend William Stryker in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: +1

Florian Munteanu

as Colossus in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: +1

Felix Kammerer

as Nightcrawler in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: +1

Lashana Lynch

as Storm in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: +1

Adam Gregory

as Cyclops in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: 0

Rachel Sennott

as Shadowcat in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: 0

Terry O'Quinn

as Professor X in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: +1

Michael Wincott

as Magneto in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: +1

Stephen Graham

as Wolverine in God Loves, Man Kills

Score: 0