Suggestions by @thegingerbreadman

Harvey Keitel

as Luigi Maroni in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Gwendoline Christie

as Sofia Falcone Gigante in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Colin Hanks

as Alberto Falcone in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Jennifer Tilly

as Carla Viti in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Cameron Britton

as Johnny Viti in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Dominic West

as Salvatore Maroni in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Dylan McDermott

as Carmine Falcone in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Michael Fimognari

as Cinematographer in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Dave Bautista

as The Phantasm in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Victoria Pedretti

as Andrea Beaumont in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Hugh Laurie

as Alfred Pennyworth in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Monica Raymund

as Detective Renee Montoya in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Robert Longstreet

as Detective Harvey Bullock in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Nicolas Cage

as Clayface in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Sasha Calle

as Catwoman in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Tom Hardy

as The Penguin in Dread the Batman

Score: +2

Thomas Doherty

as Batman in Dread the Batman

Score: +1

Matthias Schoenaerts

as Krem of the Yellow Hills in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +2

Kyle Chandler

as Hal Jordan in DCU Chapter One: Gods and Monsters

Score: +3

Kurt and Bart

as Costume Designer in Dread the Batman

Score: +2