Suggestions by @theaterfancasts

Mike Faist

as John Hinckley Jr. in Assassins

Score: +1

Ross Lynch

as John Hinckley Jr. in Assassins

Score: -1

Keith David

as The Proprietor in Assassins

Score: +1

Joey Diaz

as Samuel Byck in Assassins

Score: +1

Josh Groban

as John Wilkes Booth in Assassins

Score: +1

Cara Delevingne

as Susan in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Harry in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Daniel Radcliffe

as Susan in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: -1

Audra McDonald

as Joanne in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Stephanie Beatriz

as Marta in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Kara Young

as Amy in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Philippa Soo

as Kathy in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Jane Lynch

as Joanne in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Beanie Feldstein

as Jenny in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Will Roland

as David in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Julie Benko

as Marta in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Amanda Seyfried

as April in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Darren Criss

as Paul in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1

Chip Zien

as Larry in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +2

Melissa Rauch

as Amy in Company Live at the Hollywood Bowl

Score: +1