Suggestions by @the_man_with_no_name

Scott Eastwood

as Johnny Cage in Better Mortal Kombat Sequel

Score: -1

Cameron Monaghan

as Joker in The Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight

Score: +1

Jennifer Coolidge

as Gina Lempke in Thinner (2022)

Score: +1

Will Ferrell

as Richie Ginelli in Thinner (2022)

Score: -1

Pamela Anderson

as Stripperella in Stripperella

Score: -2

Shane Diesel

as The Dick Wolf in Striptease 2 Magic Mike

Score: +1

Rebecca Love

as Penelope in Striptease 2 Magic Mike

Score: +1

Wentworth Miller

as Chris Redfield in Resident Evil Cinematic Universe

Score: -16

Jeremy Irons

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Beyond Redemption

Score: +2

Ashton Kutcher

as Blue Beetle in Justice League Dark

Score: +1

Sean William Scott

as Booster Gold in Justice League Dark

Score: +2

Max Thieriot

as Bartosz Tiedemann in DARK (American Version)

Score: +1

Lauren Cohan

as Joker in Batman: Beyond Redemption

Score: +2

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

as Batman in Batman: Beyond Redemption

Score: +4

Paul Dano

as Riddler (2) in The Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight

Score: +1

Matthew McConaughey

as Harvey Dent in The Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Bruce Wayne in The Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight

Score: +2

Cory Michael Smith

as Riddler in The Batman: Legends of the Dark Knight

Score: -1

Numan Acar

as Rā's al Ghūl in The Batman 2

Score: +7

Cameron Monaghan

as The Clown Joker in The Batman 2

Score: +7