Suggestions by @thatartsyhorrorfan

Barbara Hershey

as Elisabeth Sparkle in The Substance (2004)

Score: +1

Dyan Cannon

as Elisabeth Sparkle in The Substance (1999)

Score: +2

Carmen Moore

as Martha in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +3

Eddie Spears

as George in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +2

Wyatt Russell

as Private Reich in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +3

Martin Starr

as Major Knox in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +2

Bill Camp

as General Slauson in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +3

Brendan Fraser

as Colonel Hart in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +3

Rory Culkin

as Private Toffler in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +5

Richard Harmon

as Private Cleaves in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +2

James McAvoy

as Colonel Ives in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +4

Robert Pattinson

as Captain John Boyd in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +5

Johnny Greenwood

as Composer in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +3

Coralie Fargeat

as Director in Ravenous (2019)

Score: +3

Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson

as Ganon in The Legend of Zelda

Score: +1

Kevin Durand

as Ganon in The Legend of Zelda

Score: +1

Anna Paquin

as Alabama Whitman in True Romance (2003)

Score: +2

Hayden Christensen

as Clarence Worley in True Romance (2003)

Score: +4

Stephen King

as Lionel Twain in Murder by Death (2026)

Score: +1

Marlee Matlin

as Yetta in Murder by Death (2026)

Score: 0