Suggestions by @tessamercier1

Lucas Till

as Kyle McNulty in Two Can Keep a Secret

Score: +2

Sofia Carson

as Katherine Riva in Malibu Rising

Score: -6

Gabbie Clayburn

as Katherine Riva in Malibu Rising

Score: -5

Jake T. Austin

as Hudson Riva in Malibu Rising

Score: +6

Ariana Greenblatt

as Young Nina Riva in Malibu Rising

Score: +2

Melissa Barrera

as Nina Riva in Malibu Rising

Score: +3

Adelaide Kane

as Young Allison Story in The Cousins

Score: +1

Nicholas Cantu

as Jonah Theodore Story in The Cousins

Score: +1

Lizzy Greene

as Aubrey Elizabeth Story in The Cousins

Score: +2

Dylan Arnold

as Jonah North in The Cousins

Score: -1

Natasha Liu Bordizzo

as Mildred Margaret Story-Takahashi in The Cousins

Score: +1

Adeline Rudolph

as Mildred Margaret Story-Takahashi in The Cousins

Score: 0

Alex Fitzalan

as Jonah North in The Cousins

Score: -1

Emily Alyn Lind

as Aubrey Elizabeth Story in The Cousins

Score: +2

Ashley Liao

as Mildred Margaret Story-Takahashi in The Cousins

Score: +1

Lily Collins

as Sarah Corcoran in Two Can Keep a Secret

Score: +1

Blake Lively

as Alicia Kelly in Two Can Keep a Secret

Score: 0

Elizabeth Reaser

as Alicia Kelly in Two Can Keep a Secret

Score: +2

Rudy Pankow

as Kyle McNulty in Two Can Keep a Secret

Score: +2

Alisa Allapach

as Daisy Kwon in Two Can Keep a Secret

Score: 0