Suggestions by @teeyutes

Dick Van Dyke

as George Bailey in It’s a Wonderful Life (1956)

Score: +2

James Coburn

as J. Jonah Jameson in Sam Raimi's Spider-Man Trilogy (1982-1987)

Score: +1

Edward Arnold

as Nelson Longhurst in Carbon Copy (1951)

Score: +1

Sidney Poitier

as Roger Porter in Carbon Copy (1951)

Score: +1

Christopher Lee

as Father Lankester Merrin in The Exorcist (1963)

Score: +1

Adolph Caesar

as John Prentice Sr in Guess who’s coming to dinner 1987

Score: +1

Glynis Johns

as Nancy in Oliver! (1958)

Score: +1

Robert Shaw

as Bill Sikes in Oliver! (1958)

Score: +1

Laurence Olivier

as Fagin in Oliver! (1958)

Score: +1

Harve Presnell

as Wild Bill Hickok in Calamity Jane (1963)

Score: +1

Tammy Grimes

as Calamity Jane in Calamity Jane (1963)

Score: +1

John McGiver

as Diz Moore in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1959)

Score: +1

John Huston

as Senator Joseph Paine in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1959)

Score: +1

Burgess Meredith

as Jim Taylor in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1959)

Score: +1

Amanda Peet

as Bonnie Rayburn in City Slickers (2001)

Score: +1

Kevin Pollak

as Mitch Robbins in City Slickers (2001)

Score: +1

Alec Baldwin

as Ed Furillo in City Slickers (2001)

Score: +1

John Amos

as Ben Jessup in City Slickers (2001)

Score: +1

Gene Hackman

as Curly Washburn in City Slickers (2001)

Score: +1

Steve Zahn

as Phil Berquist in City Slickers (2001)

Score: +1