Suggestions by @tebbyt

Chris Pine

as Jack Skelington in The Nightmare Before Christmas (Live Action)

Score: -2

Joseph Gordon-Levitt

as Jack Skelington in The Nightmare Before Christmas (Live Action)

Score: -1

Iain De Caestecker

as Donalbain in Macbeth

Score: +1

Rose Leslie

as Lady Macduff in Macbeth

Score: 0

Tommy Flanagan

as Porter in Macbeth

Score: +1

Rory McCann

as Murderer 2 in Macbeth

Score: +1

James Robinson

as Murderer 1 in Macbeth

Score: +1

Alan Cumming

as Angus in Macbeth

Score: +1

Henry Ian Cusick

as Ross in Macbeth

Score: +1

John Bell

as Fleance in Macbeth

Score: +1

Karen Gillan

as Hecate in Macbeth

Score: +1

Ewan McGregor

as Lennox in Macbeth

Score: +1

Richard Madden

as Malcolm in Macbeth

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as Macduff in Macbeth

Score: +1

Brian Cox

as King Duncan in Macbeth

Score: +1

David Tennant

as Banquo in Macbeth

Score: +1

Kelly Macdonald

as Witch 3 in Macbeth

Score: +1

Michelle Gomez

as Witch 2 in Macbeth

Score: +1

Emma Laird

as Witch 1 in Macbeth

Score: +1

Tilda Swinton

as Lady Macbeth in Macbeth

Score: +2