Suggestions by @tearjerker

Erinn Hayes

as Marilyn Torres in The Final Girl Support Group

Score: +2

Thomas Lennon

as Harlan Jaffers in Clown in a Cornfield

Score: +1

Sam Elliott

as Sherriff Dunne in Clown in a Cornfield

Score: +2

Natalie Alyn Lind

as Ronnie in Clown in a Cornfield

Score: 0

David Harbour

as Edward Turner in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Steve Zahn

as Mike in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

James Spader

as Steve Bradford in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Florence Pugh

as Tina Landry in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Topher Grace

as Mark Harper in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Will Poulter

as Brad Landry in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Samara Weaving

as Hannah Chambers in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Bradley Cooper

as Edward Turner in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: -1

Stephen Lang

as Hal Ordover in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Izzy King

as Tommy Walker in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Will Patton

as Sheriff Nelson in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Hailee Steinfeld

as Barbara in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

suggestions

as Barbara in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: -1

Justin Theroux

as Martin Booth in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Tom Hanks

as Lee Burgundy in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1

Adam Scott

as Christopher Brummit in The Haunted Forrest Tour

Score: +1