Suggestions by @tavitaylorde

Josh O'Connor

as Luc Lémy in The Beautiful Ones

Score: -1

Freddie Fox

as Étienne Lémy in The Beautiful Ones

Score: +1

Callum Turner

as Étienne Lémy in The Beautiful Ones

Score: -1

Leo Woodall

as Dickie Greenleaf in The Talented Mr. Ripley (2023)

Score: +1

Matthew Macfadyen

as Gaétan Beaulieu in The Beautiful Ones

Score: +1

Haley Bennett

as Valerie Beaulieu in The Beautiful Ones

Score: +1

Dev Patel

as Hector Auvrey in The Beautiful Ones

Score: +1

Helena Howard

as Antonina Beaulieu in The Beautiful Ones

Score: +1

Alexander Skarsgård

as Terry Hunt in We Sold Our Souls

Score: +1

Matt Berry

as JD in We Sold Our Souls

Score: +1

Paul Schneider

as Scottie Rocket in We Sold Our Souls

Score: +1

Joel McHale

as Rob Anthony in We Sold Our Souls

Score: +1

Otmara Marrero

as Melanie Gutiérrez in We Sold Our Souls

Score: +1

Mike Colter

as Tuck Merryweather in We Sold Our Souls

Score: +1

Melanie Lynskey

as Kris Pulaski in We Sold Our Souls

Score: +1

Sophie Nélisse

as Sarah White in HEROES OF CHAOS: Super Ranking of Gods

Score: +1

Emory Cohen

as Vance Astrovik in Avengers Academy MCU Adaptation

Score: +1

Bob Odenkirk

as Jack Houston in In the Angel's City (ruled by popular demand)

Score: +1

Alan Ruck

as Jack Houston in In the Angel's City (ruled by popular demand)

Score: +2

Imogen Poots

as Aimee-Leigh Brown in Those Who Trespass Against Us

Score: +2