Suggestions by @sus_spence1

Jesse L. Martin

as Sandy Claws in Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas: A Broadway Musical

Score: +1

Denée Benton

as Sally in Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas: A Broadway Musical

Score: 0

Stephanie Hsu

as Shock in Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas: A Broadway Musical

Score: +1

Telly Leung

as Lock in Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas: A Broadway Musical

Score: +1

Lucas Steele

as Jack Skellington in Tim Burton's The Nightmare Before Christmas: A Broadway Musical

Score: +2

Ariana DeBose

as Pearl in Starlight Express: The Movie

Score: +1

Demi Lovato

as Electra in Starlight Express: The Movie

Score: 0

Hailee Steinfeld

as Susie in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +4

Jamie Foxx

as Grillby in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +2

Jason Sudeikis

as Noelle's Father in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +2

Jonathan Majors

as Spamton in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: 0

Bo Burnham

as Burgerpants in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +3

Louis Hynes

as Berdly in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +2

Sophia Anne Caruso

as Noelle in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +5

Kenneth Branagh

as Roulxs Kaard in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: 0

Jenny Slate

as Queen in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +2

Sam Elliott

as King in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +1

Archie Yates

as Lancer in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +1

Sofia Wylie

as Susie in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +1

Caleb McLaughlin

as Kris in Undertale/Deltarune (Netflix Adaptation)

Score: +1