Suggestions by @superbrosyt

Max Spielberg

as Producer in Jaws 16

Jason Segel

as Jason Segel in Jaws 16

Paul Rudd

as Paul Rudd in Jaws 16

Tord Larsson

as Tord Larsson in Jaws 16

Dave Franco

as Dave Franco in Jaws 16

Christopher Mintz-Plasse

as Christopher Mintz-Plasse in Jaws 16

Logan Moreau

as Ethan Dennis in Jaws 16

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Sarah Michelle Gellar in Jaws 16

Matt Hargreaves

as Matt Hargreaves in Jaws 16

Thomas Ridgewell

as Thomas Ridgewell in Jaws 16

Edd Gould

as Edd Gould in Jaws 16

Sam Rockwell

as Harry Lawrence in Jaws 16

Josh Gad

as Josh Gad in Jaws 16

Mindy Kaling

as Mindy Kaling in Jaws 16

Paddy Holland

as Max Parker in Jaws 16

Jonah Hill

as Jonah Hill in Jaws 16

Rihanna

as Rihanna in Jaws 16

Steven Spielberg

as Director in Jaws 16

Peter Benchley

as Writer in Jaws 16

Jacob Tremblay

as Adam Maguire in Jaws 16