Suggestions by @superbrosyt

Rowan Blanchard

as Claire Nunez in Sugar Rush

Zendaya Coleman

as Mia Dobry in Sugar Rush

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Regan York in Sugar Rush

Bonnie Wright

as Jenny Bennett in Sugar Rush

Tom Felton

as Payton Olijar in Sugar Rush

Andy Samberg

as Declan Misch in Sugar Rush

Ben Schwartz

as Guido Vesteca in Sugar Rush

Dacre Montgomery

as Alberto Scrofono in Sugar Rush

John Mulaney

as Luca Paguro in Sugar Rush

Emma Watson

as Hannah DeVries in Sugar Rush

Matt Hargreaves

as Matt Hargreaves in Sugar Rush

Edd Gould

as Edd Gould in Sugar Rush

Thomas Ridgewell

as Thomas Ridgewell in Sugar Rush

Christopher Mintz-Plasse

as Nick Harvard in Sugar Rush

Jonah Hill

as Charles Chowder in Sugar Rush

Danny McBride

as D.J. Walters in Sugar Rush

Bill Hader

as Geno Frisia Jr. in Sugar Rush

Paul Rudd

as Harold Hutchins in Sugar Rush

Jason Segel

as George Beard in Sugar Rush

Jay Baruchel

as Connor Angie in Sugar Rush