Suggestions by @subtlycharmingdream

Octavia Spencer

as Rhonda in Papa Louie

Alyssa Jirrels

as Radlynn in Papa Louie

Angela Kinsey

as Quinn in Papa Louie

Morgan Freeman

as Professor Fitz in Papa Louie

Paul Lieberstein

as Pinch Hitwell in Papa Louie

Lucy Boynton

as Perri in Papa Louie

Madison Davenport

as Olivia in Papa Louie

Stephanie Cole

as Olga in Papa Louie

Archie Yates

as Nick in Papa Louie

Taylor Hickson

as Nevada in Papa Louie

Lucas Till

as Mousse in Papa Louie

George Blagden

as Moe in Papa Louie

David Krumholtz

as Mayor Mallow in Papa Louie

James Marsden

as Matt in Papa Louie

Anne Hathaway

as Mandi in Papa Louie

Toby Regbo

as Legolas in The Lord of the Rings

Antonia Thomas

as Lisa in Papa Louie

Roman Griffin Davis

as LePete in Papa Louie

Luca Hollestelle

as Koilee in Papa Louie

Steve Harvey

as Kingsley in Papa Louie